First, although shrek is illtempered, like the beast, but his bad temperament is a result of his appearance, rather than. Shrek and the reinvented fairy tale clayton county library. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet. Compare and contrast reading a book and watching a film essay. Since it opened last week, shrek has become a boxoffice hit, with the second highest debut for an animated film after. First we will observe the scene from the movie and then go onto the musical afterward to compare. Shrek posted on november 28, 20 january 22, 2014 by mrsshaia last week i wrote about my first mixed age program i will be doing once a month. Pros and cons for each will be given and a winner will be chosen. Ways that the book and movie are the same include characters. Book vs movie comparison of shrek by positively planning tpt. Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. Movie leonidas is no softie he is king of a patriarchal society, after all but he regards his men more as fellow soldiers and countrymen than subjects. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet movies. It has been retold many different times in both written and film text and it is effective and timeless throughout the use of many techniques.
There are both similarities and differences with the two pieces, some are obvious and others are buried deep within the context of the two. Oct 4, 2012 venn diagram comparing shrek the book and the shrek the movie stay safe and healthy. With a book you can describe places that come out of your imagination, which could never become reality no matter how hard hollywood tries. Frozen 20, minions 2015, shrek 2001, inside out 2015, despicable me 2 20 having trouble thinking of good comparisons. However, movies takes at most 4 hours of your time, such as the movie lord of the rings 3, but the average length of a movie is between 1. Venn diagram comparing shrek the book and the shrek the movie. Movie comparison analysis as your students view the movie version of the giver after reading the novel, they will enjoy using this 2page graphic organizer to record their observations. The movie shrek isnt ugly, hes just goofy looking, because hollywood can never bring itself to do ugly all the way ok, the elephant man was ugly, and charles laughton was one ugly hunchback of. Jan 22, 2008 book leonidas is a hard king, who addresses his soldiers as children and is quick to mete out discipline. By florencemcc tuesday, may 8, 2018 1 book vs movie adaptation, animation, books, childrens books, film permalink 0 i remember when shrek first came out way back in 2001. The movie harrison bergeron is based off of its short story, yet their stories are quite different from each other. Posted on november 28, 20 january 22, 2014 by mrsshaia. The movie has mike myers as shrek, eddie murphy as donkey, cameron diaz as fiona, and john lithgow as farquaad, directed by andrew adamson and vicky jenson, and produced by dreamworks, not disney. The movie keeps the same premise of the two children being left home with nothing much to do, but it takes the liberty of changing and adding details to lenghten and modernize the story.
Apr 24, 2011 the movie the cat in the hat starring mike myers and dakota fanning is quite different from the original dr. Mar 07, 20 the movie harrison bergeron is based off of its short story, yet their stories are quite different from each other. This is a comparison video between my real life shrek intro and the movies intro. The dwarves are described the dwarves who come to as having brightlycoloured bilbos door have short beards and cloaks. The name shrek is the romanization of the yiddish word. Life of pi movie and movie comparison 827 words 4 pages. Since he was the author of the novel, though, the essence of the book transferred onto film nearly flawlessly, even while he hacked away the book s story to include only the essentials. On the other hand, another of my favorite computer animated movie was produced by dreamworks which was, shrek 2001. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. Themoviesanddreamworksanimation therearefourmoviesthathavebeenspunofffromthebookshrek theoriginal.
Why shrek the third is a cinematic disaster youtube. Compare and contrast reading a book and watching a film. A person must use their mind to be able to describe what they think a character may sound like, look like, mannerisms, clothes they would wear, and where they live. Ways that the book and movie are the same include setting. The movie the cat in the hat starring mike myers and dakota fanning is quite different from the original dr. The movie, 2081, based on vonneguts novel, wasnt as good as the book. Writers christian karlsson, pontus winnberg, henrik jonback, cathy dennis.
Jul 16, 2010 in the movie, shrek has more of a relationship with donkey and has a different motive for saving the princess. How shrek was turned into a broadway musical the new. If youre desperate for some more shrek videos, heres a link to a couple you might enjoy. In the movie, shrek has more of a relationship with donkey and has a different motive for saving the princess. Comparison where the wild things are book and movie essay. A theatrical engagement is defined as the movie playing in a single theater for one week. This simple venn diagram was used to compare and contrast the shrek book by william steig and the first shrek movie directed by andrew adamson and vicky.
I believe changes were made to make things more interesting. This is a comparison video between my real life shrek intro and the movie s intro. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. Free use these two printables after you have read the book and then seen the movie version. When i was a kid, one of my favorite story books was, where the wild things are by maurice sendak. He wants only to be left alone, perhaps because he is not such an ogre after all but merely a lonely creature.
It is roughly based on a fairy tale picture book shrek. Give each child a bingo card, a red crayon and a green crayon. When we read a book we create a visual image in our heads, whereas when we watch a movie the image is already created. Thorins beard is blue and he has a the hobbit was aimed at younger readers, so the characters often broke into beards and dress in dark colours. The scene which im going to compare between each medium will be the scene in which shrek interrupts the wedding between fiona and lord farquaad. Ways that the book and movie are different include. Domestic box office comparison between shrek the musical 20 and shrek 2001 movie comparison. Great for comparing and contrasting and thinking critically about how the movie was made. In order of popularity, there is the shrek of the movies shrek the third opens friday. When you read a book you have it is a must to use your imagination to build the world of your book. The most noticeable difference, as is the case with most film. Naturally, the graphic novel follows the conventions of comic book heroes, while the movie employs magic realism to raise the spartans to mythical proportions. The original childrens book by william steig, published in 1990, is a lot shorter. Ways that the book and movie are different include characters.
Before the princess bride movie, goldman wrote screenplays for butch cassidy and the sundance kid, the stepford wives, and others. They were also seen as ugly and gross, and because of this, people assumed that shrek was mean and dangerous. I will be focusing on picture books that were made into movies. Please practice handwashing and social distancing, and check out our resources for adapting to these times. With references to touching the void and another book. Venn diagram comparing shrek the book and the shrek the. A nasty green ogre who is the main character in the book. Shrek and the reinvented fairy tale clayton county. As with its predecessor, it has quite a bit of adult innuendo, potty humor, and gross. Shrek venn diagram compare and contrast with images. Books and movies have similarities and differences. Shreks voice is now performed by mike myers, with a voice thats an echo of his fat bastard the scotsman with a molasses brogue in austin powers.
However, the book does not give much motivation behind shrek finding the princess. Please be aware before purchasing that the picture book shrek. Shrek is feared and left alone because he is an ogre. The help book and movie differences essay example graduateway. I did, i admit, compare my narrative abilities to those of tucci and streep. It has basically the same plot and characters and even much of the same dialogue as is in the original shrek movie but with added songanddance numbers. November marks the release of several movies based on young adult novels, which makes it the perfect time for this kind of study. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet movies shakespeares romeo and juliet is a play based on love, hate, tragedy and sacrifice.
Starting with the post you are reading right now, i be conducting book vs. Today, fairy tales are parodied, ironized, metafictionalized, politically adjusted and popculture saturated, making for glorious send. Shrek by florencemcc tuesday, may 8, 2018 1 book vs movie adaptation, animation, books, childrens books, film permalink 0 i remember when shrek first came out way back in 2001. The movie shrek isnt ugly, hes just goofy looking, because hollywood can never bring itself to do ugly all the way ok, the elephant man was ugly, and. Dreamworks shrek book by mileymouse101 on deviantart. As a piece of my childhood, that simple story about max and the wild rumpus meant a lot to me. And you really cant tell the best bunch of the two no matter how conclusive your defense might be. Shrek tells the tale of a lonely ogre trying to find his way though life in the forest. So, for example, a film that plays in 3,000 theaters in.
Parents need to know that shrek the musical is a dvd release of the broadway musical based on the shrek animated movie. With a partner, small group, or independently, students analyze and describe differences and. Comparison where the wild things are book and movie. In both versions, shrek is on an adventure across the countryside.
It is, however, great for little kids, maybe even those learning to read, and its fun in the same way that dr. For example, charlotte yelling at hilly to get off of her property is much more interesting than her simply. Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of. Frankenstein comparison of modern and old monsters. The differences in leonidas portrayal set the two apart.
You just cannot compare and contrast movies from books because it would be saying or identifying the best bunch of the two. Sep 03, 2018 shrek follows the same basic storyline as beauty and the beast, with a monster falling in love with a beautiful princess, thus breaking an enchantress curse, but it also differs from it in several important ways. In medieval times, ogres were seen as large, flesheating monsters that could kill almost any person with ease. The hobbit book movie book movie there are only a few songs in the film. It is a commonly agreed upon statement, that the book is always better than the movie, and this is one of the many cases where this statement shines. See more ideas about compare and contrast, books vs movies and the lorax book. Writing a book is a lot easier than making a movie. One twitter user posted a thread that compares got characters and plot with the beloved animated classic shrek movies and the side by side comparison similarities are almost too coincidental.
Aug 22, 2018 this is a comparison video between my real life shrek intro and the movie s intro. In an odd twist, the movie is better than the book. Difference between movies and books difference between. And even though there are similarities, the amount of differences between the pieces is. How shrek was turned into a broadway musical the new york. The book is pulpy goodness, an admitted bid for riches by puzo, who was then better known as a literary author. William steigs subversive misanthropy is jettisoned for winking innuendo in the movie version of his childrens book. In his article how shrek changed fairy tales may 21, 2007, time magazine film critic james poniewozik observes how fairy tales of old are a far cry from the nice, gentle treatments of the disney animated movies. May 17, 2007 in his article how shrek changed fairy tales may 21, 2007, time magazine film critic james poniewozik observes how fairy tales of old are a far cry from the nice, gentle treatments of the disney animated movies.
Shrek follows the same basic storyline as beauty and the beast, with a monster falling in love with a beautiful princess, thus breaking an enchantress curse, but it also differs from it in several important ways. Apart from losing steigs exclamation mark, the movie shrek is very much founded in. Free essays on comparison of novel and movie harrison bergeron. Feb 05, 2010 on rereading william steigs book shrek. To even tackle the difference between a movie and a book is a mortal sin. Shrek is an ogre who lives in a swamp surrounded by keep out and beware the ogre.
1468 337 1227 878 1236 1034 213 844 138 872 854 1123 574 1415 223 429 1110 1015 543 431 1506 1677 601 392 31 1205 743 1359 683 1192 1143 347 1001 272